|
A smash at the film festival in its home town of Berlin, this film tells a
story now familiar from Erica Fischer's prize-winning book and
documentary of the same name. Juliane Kohler and Maria Schrader, two of
Germany's most lauded actresses, play Lily Wust and Felice
Schragenheim, given the code/nicknames Aimee and Jaguar in Felice's
writing.
Lily is a fine upstanding Deutschemadchen, making babies for Hitler's
troops - rather more of Hitler's troops than her husband suspects, as
she shags her way through Berlin while her husband is at the front.
Felice is a Jewish Communist lesbian working undercover for the
Zeitung, stealing lists of names of Jews to be deported from her boss who
is a big Nazi cheese, and helping smuggle people out of Germany. She is
part of a small underground network of Jews who stayed in Berlin at great
personal risk to work as spies and resistance. Her circle of young women
friends provide each other with jobs, food and love. When Felice's
girlfriend introduces her to her employer, Lily, a passion is set in
motion that endangers the whole organisation. At first, Lily is
charmed by Jaguar's erotic poems and she slowly becomes deeply
involved with Felice, struggling against her strict upbringing and
the impossible situation. When Felice finally tells her that she is
Jewish, the whole cinema holds its breath.
This film has been described as a lesbian Romeo and Juliet, and in a sense
it's true. Both Felice and Lily are immature as lovers when the film
opens, both high desirous and desirable, given to flings and flinging
away partners when they are done. Their affair is a learning process for
them both - a learning of both the limits and limitlessness of desire.
Even in her precarious situation, Felice pursues Lily ardently, and
the film makes a study of the small and great betrayals human beings make
in war. Lily's husband is painted as more of a boor on screen than he comes
across in the book, but the film retains the nuances of Berlin life so
rarely seen in movies about the war era. Lily is not the only one to come to
accept and protect Felice as a Jew, and the girls makes themselves a life
that mingles daily survival and wild parties that - while dangerous -
suggests alternate histories within our over-riding understanding
of Hitler's Germany. The persistence of the human spirit in love is
rendered here in desperate vivid colours.
So far, so worthy. A film tailor-made for niche-market film festivals.
Yet there is more to Aimee and Jaguar than that. Its handling of the
documentary material is always close, but given cinematic character
not only by the rich palette of the designer and cinematographer -
clothes act as symbols for moods - but by the strong script which isn't
afraid to put opinions, and even poetry, in the mouths of its
characters. The ensemble playing on both sides - Felice's friends,
Lily's family - is material to the persuasive vivaciousness of the
film. One feels that the director has given his movie the same character
as Lily and Felice's relationship: beautiful amid but not in ignorance
of the horror, joyful because aware that time is short, and tragic
without being morbid. The inventiveness of the intimate scenes
between the lovers, which initially use clothing and food as code for
love, and develop into dancing, kissing and sex, separates the film
from its documentary nature. Cinematographically and structurally,
it has the feeling of classic war films like Brief Encounter, where the
relationship becomes a metaphor for the politics of the outside world.
The sensuousness of the movie is a victory over a film industry that
would feed us our historical cautionary tales in big budget digitised
extravaganzas. As in Pearl Harbor, the love of a good woman represents
both salvation and the drive to fight evil, but here the woman herself
enters the fight on even terms. And those even terms are rare enough.
Perhaps describing the film as a lesbian The English Patient might come
closer to both the intensity of the passion and the opposition between
the affair and the world raging outside. But the tragedy here is not
personal in its execution. In the end, the state intervenes, marking in
that single act the destruction of privacy and private space that
Fascism necessitated.
Aimee and Jaguar is a painstaking effort to reconstruct that private
space, to bring a secret history to the screen without making of it a
freak show or an object lesson. The carefully-wrought individual
characters argue that this is their story, a single voice speaking for
itself, restoring the individuality that the Nazis took away by
transforming the world to mass movements and numbers. That Felice and
Lily, a Jewish lesbian and a Catholic Nazi mother, should speak with a
single voice in this film is a triumph over the world Fascism would have
made.
Sophie Levy
|